This week, I return to my series on how to account for modifications to equity awards—explained in 75 words or less. Today’s topic is settling equity awards in cash.
When equity awards are settled in cash, the accounting treatment will vary depending on whether it is the vested or unvested portion of the award that is being paid out. If both portions are settled in cash, the expense for each portion will have to be calculated separately.
Let’s say that an executive is granted an option with a grant date fair value of $400,000. When the option is one-quarter vested, the company pays the option holder $500,000 in cash (the option’s then-current fair value) to settle the option.
The total expense for the option can’t be less than the original grant date fair value of $400,000. Thus, if the cash payout had been only $200,000, the company would recognize $100,000 of expense for the vested portion and the remaining $300,000 of expense for the unvested portion.
The accounting treatment would be the same, except that if the vested portion of the RSU had already been paid out in stock, there would be no further expense for that portion of the award.
Two come to mind. First, any time awards are being paid out in cash it is important for the company to ensure that it has enough cash to cover the payouts.
Second, if the cash payouts are part of a pattern or create the expectation that the company will pay out awards in cash in the future, they could trigger liability treatment for the entire plan, in addition to the expense for the awards currently being settled in cash. It’s best to document any rationale for why the cash payouts should be treated as a one-time occurrence.
So many! To learn about the securities law, tax, and other considerations that apply to award modifications, check out my blog entry “5 Things to Know About Award Modifications” and this handy table summarizing the considerations for various types of modifications.
Thanks to Dan Kapinos of Aon Rewards Solutions for confirming my understanding of the accounting treatment for cash settlements.
Optimizing Equity Awards in a Down Market
Can equity awards be optimized for insulation against market declines? If 2020 is teaching us anything, it’s that companies may need to get creative in figuring out how to restore broken i...Read More
Accounting for Extending a Post-Termination Exercise Period
It’s time to return to my ongoing Read More
Accounting for Option Repricings
For this week’s blog entry, I continue my Read More
Accounting for Acceleration of Vesting Upon Termination
For this week’s blog entry, I continue my series on how to account for ...Read More
Accounting for Modifications to Performance Awards
Here’s the situation: you’ve got an equity award in which vesting is conditioned on non-market targets (i.e., targets other than stock price, market cap, or TSR) and the targets are ...Read More